Michigan Supreme Court Bars Automatic Death-in-Prison Sentences for Youngest Adults

The Michigan Supreme Court ruled last week that a mandatory sentence of life imprisonment without parole for young adults who were 19 or 20 years old at the time of the offense is a “grossly disproportionate punishment” that violates the Michigan Constitution.

The decision extends to 19- and 20-year-olds the court’s 2022 ruling in People v. Parks, which applied the federal constitutional ban on automatic life-without-parole sentences for juveniles to 18-year-olds under the broader and more protective provisions of the Michigan Constitution.

The Parks court found that late adolescent “brains are far more similar to juvenile brains . . . than to the brains of fully matured adults.” Like juveniles, late adolescents are more “susceptible to negative outside influences, including peer pressure,” and tend “to give less consideration to the costs or consequences of a decision.”

Like those of younger children, late adolescents’ brains “transform as they age, allowing them to reform into persons who are more likely to be capable of making more thoughtful and rational decisions.” The court found that “18-year-olds, much like their juvenile counterparts, are generally capable of significant change” and rehabilitation.

As a result, the Parks court held that the state’s individualized sentencing procedure for juveniles applies to 18-year-olds:

Because of the dynamic neurological changes that late adolescents undergo as their brains develop over time and essentially rewire themselves, automatic condemnation to die in prison at 18 is beyond severity—it is cruelty.

Last week’s decision came in the combined cases of Andrew Czarnecki and Montario Taylor, who were convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to mandatory life in prison without parole for offenses when they 19 and 20 years old, respectively. They argued on appeal that Parks should be extended to 19- and 20-year-olds.

Based on the “unrebutted scientific consensus” before it, the Michigan Supreme Court found that 19- and 20-year-olds share with 18-year-olds “the same mitigating characteristics of late-adolescent brain development” that distinguish children from adults for sentencing purposes and render automatic life-without-parole sentences disproportionate.

“[A]s a class, 19- and 20-year-old late adolescents are more similar to juveniles in neurological terms than they are to older adults,” the court found. “There has long been a scientific consensus that, in terms of neurological development, there is ‘no meaningful distinction’ between a 17-year-old and 18-year-old individual…But the lack of meaningful distinction does not stop at age 18.”

Indeed, the court observed, late adolescents’ capacity for rehabilitation is demonstrated by data showing that the likelihood of committing violent or property crimes decreases during a person’s twenties and continues to decline significantly as they age.

Michigan law further demonstrates society’s assessment that people between 18 and 21 “are mature enough to hold some but not all of the rights and privileges of full adulthood,” the court observed. People under 21 cannot serve as an elected state legislator in Michigan or run for U.S. Senate. And state laws protect them from “risky or potentially dangerous or addictive activities” by prohibiting under-21-year-olds from gambling, buying or using alcohol or cannabis, and obtaining a concealed pistol license.

The court concluded that the Michigan Constitution does not permit the imposition of the state’s harshest available punishment against 19- and 20-years-olds, who are “presumptively neurologically indistinguishable from either a teenage juvenile offender or an 18-year-old offender” and therefore must receive the same individualized sentencing procedure as juveniles.

“[A]s applied to defendants who were 19 or 20 years old at the time of their crime,” the court held, “a mandatory LWOP sentence that does not allow for consideration of the mitigating factors of youth or the potential for rehabilitation is a grossly disproportionate punishment” in violation of the state constitution.

The court held that this latest decision applies retroactively, allowing roughly 580 people serving sentences for first-degree murder committed when they were 19 or 20-years-old to request resentencing.

Michigan now joins Washington and Massachusetts in extending the prohibition against mandatory life-without-parole sentences to people under 21 years old, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.

Source: Equal Justice Initiative, Richard Ross, April 18, 2025

"One is absolutely sickened, not by the crimes that the wicked have committed,
but by the punishments that the good have inflicted."

— Oscar Wilde

Comments

Japan executes 'Twitter killer' who murdered nine in 2017

TOKYO — Japan on Friday executed a man dubbed the "Twitter killer" who murdered and dismembered nine people he met online, in the nation's first enactment of the death penalty since 2022. Takahiro Shiraishi, 34, was hanged for killing his young victims, all but one of whom were women, after contacting them on the social media platform now called X. He had targeted users who posted about taking their own lives, telling them he could help them in their plans, or even die alongside them. Justice Minister Keisuke Suzuki said Shiraishi's crimes, carried out in 2017, included "robbery, rape, murder... destruction of a corpse and abandonment of a corpse".

New execution methods may soon come to Florida

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. – Next month, the state of Florida will officially be allowed to use new means of executing prisoners on death row — with some caveats. That’s because of a state law (HB 903) that’s set to take effect on July 1, alongside over 120 others. The law actually makes a variety of technical changes to different issues, including prepayment of court costs, statutes of limitations on prisoner lawsuits, and location tracking for inmates. However, one of the more prominent issues tackled by the law is the death penalty. Under prior law, a death sentence carried out in Florida had to be performed via either electrocution or lethal injection. The choice of which was left up to the prisoner being executed.

Inside Japan's secretive execution jails where death row inmates are given minutes notice before facing the noose

From the outside, the Tokyo Detention House looks much like the other tall, austere buildings native to Katsushika City, but its drab facade and tree-lined grounds conceal a far more sinister reality. It is here that Japan's most deplorable criminals are plucked from their cells and hanged underneath fluorescent lights in a cold, bare wood-panelled room. There is a chillingly theatrical element to how the condemned are executed in the East Asian country - the only member of the G7 besides the US that still metes out capital punishment. Shackled prisoners are led past a small gold statue of Kannon, a Buddhist figure associated with compassion, as they enter their sterile execution chamber.

Mississippi executes Richard Jordan

Mississippi executes inmate who’s been on death row almost half a century Richard Gerald Jordan, 79, received a lethal injection at the Mississippi State Penitentiary after being on death row since 1976 Mississippi has executed Richard Gerald Jordan, the state’s longest-serving death row inmate. Jordan, 79, was put to death by lethal injection at the Mississippi State Penitentiary in Parchman Wednesday evening, nearly 50 years on from when he kidnapped and killed a bank loan officer’s wife in a violent ransom scheme.

Idaho | Death row inmate who survived execution attempt describes moment he thought he 'was dead'

The execution attempt lasted over an hour There's not many people in the world who can say they've survived an execution, but one man in the US managed exactly that. Thomas Creech has now opened up about the moment he thought he was 'dead' after things went wrong, or very right depending on your point of view, as his lethal injection somehow failed last year. Death Row has long been a source of controversy in the US, with Gregory Hunt selecting an unusual new method of execution in Alabama earlier this month.

Iran | Executions in Shiraz, Ahvaz, Qom, Zanjan, Arak

Iran Human Rights (IHRNGO); June 21, 2025: Teimur Pouladvand, Nezam Moradi, Mahmoud Dehghan and Ali Akbar Younesi were executed in a group hanging in Shiraz Central Prison. According to information obtained by Iran Human Rights, four men were hanged in Shiraz (Adel Abad) Central Prison on 17 June 2025. One of the men who was on death row for drug-related offences has been identified as Teimur Pouldvand from Aligudarz. He was arrested three years ago.

Saudi Arabia Executes Journalist After 7 Years Behind Bars

Saudi Arabia has executed journalist Turki Al-Jasser after seven years in prison, following accusations of terrorism and treason, which activists say were related to his critical social media posts about the royal family. Human rights groups have condemned the execution, citing it as part of the kingdom’s crackdown on free speech. A prominent Saudi journalist, Turki Al-Jasser, has been executed after spending seven years in prison, The Associated Press reported, citing the Saudi Press Agency. Activists cited by the AP argued that the charges against him were politically motivated, primarily tied to his social media activity.

Woman who watched nearly 300 executions explained moment she had to give it up

Michelle Lyons' job wasn't for the fainthearted A woman who watched nearly 300 death row executions take place over 12 years opened up about how her macabre career impacted her life. For more than a decade, it was part of Michelle Lyons' job description to observe the final moments of hundreds of prisoners in the US state of Texas. She says the process never 'become mundane or normal', although she did become acclimatized to it - as she went on to watch so many executions that she 'can't recall' a lot of them.

Florida executes Thomas Gudinas

Man executed for raping, killing Florida woman outside bar A man convicted of raping and killing a woman near a central Florida bar was executed Tuesday evening. Thomas Lee Gudinas, 51, received a lethal injection at Florida State Prison near Starke, following decades on death row for the 1994 killing of Michelle McGrath. His execution proceeded as scheduled after last-day appeals were denied. DOC spokesperson Ted Veerman reported that Gudinas woke up at 4:45 a.m. His last meal was a pepperoni pizza, fries, and a soda. He had one visitor today—his mother. When asked about how the DOC staff is handling the pace of executions, Veerman said the “professional” staff is doing a “fantastic job.” When the curtain to the execution room opened at 6.00pm, Gudinas was already strapped to a gurney with an IV in his left arm. Then, after the warden got off the phone with the governor’s office, he asked Gudinas whether he wanted to make a last statement. Although Gudinas’s words were inau...

Inside a Mississippi execution: Clarion Ledger reporter recounts what it was like

The visitation center at the Mississippi State Penitentiary in Parchman has no windows, just fluorescent lighting, plastic chairs and tables in a cafeteria-style room. I could technically step outside, but only through a single entrance and doing so meant going through the full security screening all over again — it didn’t feel worth it. A few friendly prison staff walked around, quietly watching us. The Wi-Fi cut in and out. All the while, I returned to the thought I was there to watch someone die.

Death Penalty News

Search This Blog